Research project
Why Things End
Studies on the Disappearance of the Amphora Phenomenon
- Duration
- 2023 - 2028
- Contact
- Mink van IJzendoorn
Introduction
This project investigates the underexplored question of why the ‘Amphora Phenomenon’ disappeared. For millennia, amphorae were the main transport containers of Antiquity and a defining feature of ancient life. This packaging mode was pivotal to storing, shipping and using wine, olive oil and other goods across Afro-Eurasia. Amphora affordances constitute key containerisation purposes: utility as handy vessels, protecting precious and perishable contents and offering a medium to communicate volume and value.
So, how and why did amphora traditions break down? My research investigates this container’s obsolescence by studying how amphorae, through their (waning) socioeconomic affordances, stopped being part of the last communities making and using them. I investigate where, when and how these affordances lessened, leading to this phenomenon’s end.
Beyond proxy-thinking: a new approach to amphorae
Amphorae have gotten much scholarly attention as proxies for reconstructing past economic performance and social interaction. However, the ending of the ‘Amphora Phenomenon’, a watershed in premodern commerce, remains uncharted. A comprehensive picture of the links between the amphora’s diminishing role, its final occurrences and the emergence of alternative forms of containerisation is absent. This interdisciplinary research will fill that lacuna. It combines SSH with Sciences by bringing together unintegrated archaeological data and novel scientific analyses with an innovative methodology inspired by exciting theoretical developments concerning human-thing-entanglement in object-oriented studies.
Amphorae will not be considered passive artefactual proxies of human activities or fixed representations of (social) identities. Rather, through their (material) properties, amphorae influenced human behaviour and experience in profound and intricate ways. Amphorae were impactful objects embedded in a world of shifting technological and cultural realities. I study the Amphora Phenomenon as a containerisation praxis in its final stages by investigating the functioning of the latest amphora generations.
Case studies
My methodology will be applied to case-study material from the (post-)medieval Aegean Sea and Iberian Peninsula. These regional ‘final occurrences’ provide provocative examples of this phenomenon’s disentanglement, disappearance and related effects. I will (archaeometrically) investigate the nature of late Aegean and Iberian amphorae and document their archaeological contexts. Subsequently, I will explore and assess a plurality of (non)human factors potentially contributing to amphora obsolescence. This ensures an in-depth inquiry into the multifaceted problem of amphora ending.
Innovation, change and ‘creative destruction’
More broadly, my project provides archaeological reflections on the causes and effects of innovation. Breakthroughs and breakdowns are two sides of the same coin. Change never happens in a void. Innovation also entails ‘creative destruction’: entrenched technologies and deeply-valued traditions get challenged by ‘the new’ that may supplant the ‘old stuff’. In archaeology, beginnings (‘the first’, ‘the earliest’) are studied very often; not endings. Such disinterest is undeserved because a ‘sense of ending’ is an important lived reality in the past and today. I address that imbalance by explicitly focusing on the end of a major phenomenon in Mediterranean history. I consider the reasons and implications for societies in the Mediterranean and beyond losing/abandoning a successful, widespread, age-old container tradition. My research will open up a fresh perspective for amphora studies. Additionally, it contributes to wider debates on change and (dis)continuation; and the question why things end.
Research questions
- What are the characteristics of the last-recognisable amphora generations?
- How and why did these amphora traditions break down?
- What was the course of their disappearance?
- What were the societal implications of the Amphora Phenomenon’s end?
- In what way does an explicit focus on 'ending' (vis-à-vis innovation) add to a better understanding of change in the study of material culture?